When Leadership Agreement Doesn’t Leave the Meeting
Following through together makes a shared decision credible to everyone else.

I was once part of a leadership team that was very good at agreeing in meetings. Following through together was another matter.
Onboarding was one example. We would agree on how new team members should be brought into the organization, and I would return to my team and implement what we had decided. I took those decisions seriously. If we had established an onboarding process as a leadership team, I presented it as the way we were going to do things.
Then my team would discover that other teams weren’t following the same process.
That put me in a frustrating position. I had asked people to invest time and effort in something I had communicated as an organizational expectation. Now I was explaining why that expectation seemed to apply to us while others were doing things differently. I felt foolish, and my team had a reasonable question: Why were we doing this if everyone else wasn’t?
I stood by the process and told them I would address the inconsistency with the leadership team. At our next semi-monthly meeting, I would bring it up. Often, the response was to laugh it off. Later, when my team started getting results, others would follow suit. I always felt like the guinea pig.
There is nothing wrong with testing a process before introducing it across an organization. A pilot can help leaders learn what works, identify problems, and make improvements. But that needs to be the agreement from the beginning. The leader and team doing the testing should know that is their role. Otherwise, one team carries the work of implementation while everyone else waits to see whether it is worth doing.
The consequences extend beyond an inconsistent onboarding experience. When leaders agree to a process and then make separate choices about whether to use it, they weaken the credibility of the leaders who follow through. They also teach employees to question whether the next announced decision is an expectation or simply something their manager has chosen to enforce.
That makes future changes harder. People remember the time they were told, “This is how we’re doing it,” only to discover that wasn’t true across the organization.
Leadership teams need room for disagreement before a decision is made. If someone believes a proposed process won’t work for their team, that concern belongs in the discussion. There may be valid reasons for different approaches. Working through those differences is part of reaching a decision people can carry out.
Before leaving the meeting, leaders should be able to explain what was decided, who it applies to, when it takes effect, and where flexibility remains. They also need to agree on how concerns or changes will be handled once implementation begins. Quietly choosing a different approach leaves other leaders and their teams to manage the confusion.
Agreement in a meeting creates an expectation among the people sitting at the table. Following through together is what makes that agreement credible to everyone else.








